Amish Buns (Grandma’s Cinnamon Rolls)

RuthAnn & Elvin Zimmerman, Live in North east Iowa on 21 acres with our 7 children. They have lived on their acreage for 20 years now.

They have a couple different breeds of cows for milk and beef, Mangalitsa hogs, chickens and 2 Donkeys.


RuthAnns husband works full time but finds time to to the ‘heavy lifting’ of the homestead while her and the children do the day to day chores of the animals and in the summer in their 8000 sq feet garden planting, weeding and harvesting.


Their oldest child, Kristina, is married and lives near by, and their other children still live at home, ages 18,13,11,8,5,4.


I can remember sitting at the table watching my mom make a large batch of Amish Buns. She would have her very largest bowl over flowing with the best yeast dough ever!


If you’ve ever worked along side Amish or Mennonite women in their kitchen you know that they are the owners of some of the largest stainless steel bowls you’ve ever seen!!


The Amish and mennonite women can whip up 12 dozen cinnamon rolls or a dozen pies with little to no heads up. They can make gallons of soup and hundreds of dinner rolls for funerals or a barn raising all without running to the grocery store! Because their Larders are stocked with all the supplies they need! 

These women are one of the greatest examples of Proverbs 31 women I’ve ever had the pleasure of knowing!  


These women, my grandmas, my mom, my aunts and great aunts, they passed these skills on down the line to their daughters and grand daughters and although my husband and I have left the mennonite faith I treasure and value the homemaking skills that I have because of my mennonite heritage! 


Im sharing with you one of my all time favorite recipes that has been passed down through the generations. 

Before you have a chance to be startled about the mashed potatoes in the ingredient list, let me explain a bit. 


Potatoes are rich in potassium, causing the yeast to rise quickly.


Potatoes also help retain water which helps the rolls stay moist.


We are German/ Pa Dutch, we find a way to use potatoes in every dish. 

Amish Buns (Cinnamon Rolls)


2 T yeast in

2 Cups warm water

let set until foaming


1 T sugar

4 Cups flour

Let rise until double


2 cups mashed potatoes 

(I use instant potatoes prepared according to box directions) 

1 T salt

1 cup melted butter


5 beaten eggs


1 cup sugar


6-8 cups flour ( until dough is no longer sticking to your fingers)


Let rise until double 


Divide dough into 4-5 sections, roll out one section at a time, roll into a rectangle, as thin as possible, spread your dough generously with additional softened butter, cover butter with nice thick layer of brown sugar and sprinkle with cinnamon.


Roll your rectangle starting with the long side and cut into 3/4 to 1 inch thick slices using a thread to cut. See photo. 

Space your cinnamon rolls into a baking dish, with about 1/4 inch space between each roll.


Let the rolls rise another time until double and then bake at 350 until they are just starting to turn a bit tan over top. 


Im sorry I never time my baked goods, just watch them for doneness. 


This recipe makes about 4 dozen cinnamon rolls.


I put these into the freezer, unfrosted. When I want to serve them I’ll put them into a 200 degree oven for about 30 min and then frost them.


For frosting I whip together equal parts butter and cream cheese, then add powdered sugar to taste along with a pinch of salt and a dash of vanilla. 




Please join us by sharing, continuing the conversation below, and connecting with RuthAnn at the following:


MORE Stories

Holiday Stained Glass Windows with RuthAnn

Stained glass windows date back to the 7th century. With the earliest known reference dating
from 675 AD when workmen were imported from France to Britain to Glaze the windows of a

Read More

Quick-Rise Weeknight Pizza Dough

Like many in this homesteading space, this has been a completely unexpected journey for our family.
Even 10 years ago I would have laughed at the thought of getting up to milk a cow each morning and
canning endless amounts of tomatoes…

Read More

Wild Mushroom Risotto by The Hopewell Homestead

I am a Hopesteader. I haven’t always tried to look for the silver lining in most any situation. It’s a skill that has encouraged me to spur on and learn and read and do and gain experience by turning knowledge into wisdom…

Read More

Raw Milk Cheese

The absolute best part of this cheese recipe-there’s no stove work involved, at all! So they’ll be no sweating over the stove, or heating up the homestead during these hot summer months, with this recipe!

Chèvre is my go to cheese! I milk the goats, go inside and filter it right into a jar, and start the cheese from that very point! The doe’s body temperature is just perfect for starting the cheese on your countertop. And it doesn’t get much easier than that!…

Read More

Simple Wheat Bread Recipe

Simple Wheat Bread Recipe

This is a great, simple recipe that can be quickly thrown together multiple times a week for the perfect, from-scratch, whole wheat bread recipe. It’s a half wheat, half white flour recipe with a slightly nutty flavor, a hint of sweetness from the honey, and the perfect texture. I love that this recipe is so versatile that it can be sliced as an addition to a cozy soup dinner or hold perfectly for spread and sandwiches. I make this recipe multiple times a week in our home. If you’re on the hunt for the perfect recipe to jump into making bread at home, you’ve come to the right place.

Read More

Our Homesteading “Why”

Greetings! I’m Mandy Vander Kolk, a joyfully married mother of three, suburban homesteader, and sourdough enthusiast! From very early on, I have had a great love for the natural world.

Read More

Two-Loaf Artisan Sourdough Bread

Soon after I began my sourdough journey a few years ago, it quickly became very clear that one loaf was never enough for our family! Between my husband and I and our three children, we can easily devour an entire loaf in one sitting….

Read More

The Giving Pie

This recipe is nothing exciting, there I’ve said it. But I’ve got a lot on my heart and fruit I’m hoping to share will you; it may fill you in ways no dinner can…

Read More

Join In The Conversation

Notify of

1 Comment
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

A Patchwork of Homestead Mamas

An inspiring & encouraging community of Homestead Mamas. For growers, hunters, foragers, & explorers; with little hands & little hearts alongside.

Join Our Community